Customer Satisfaction

Customer Satisfaction and Service Quality Models for Research

Compare common satisfaction and service quality models, including expectation-disconfirmation, SERVQUAL, ACSI, and Kano, for research design.

On this page
  1. Customer satisfaction and service quality models in brief
  2. Expectation-disconfirmation
  3. SERVQUAL and service quality
  4. The ACSI-style structural model
  5. The Kano model
  6. Choosing a model for your research
  7. Using models with caution
  8. Next steps

Customer satisfaction and service quality models in brief

A model is a simplified framework that describes what drives satisfaction and how to measure it. Several models are used in customer satisfaction research. Expectation-disconfirmation focuses on how an experience compares with expectations. SERVQUAL and its variants focus on service quality. ACSI-style models show how drivers lead to satisfaction and loyalty. The Kano model sorts features by their effect on satisfaction. Each answers a different question, so the right choice depends on your research objective.

Expectation-disconfirmation

The expectation-disconfirmation view holds that customers form expectations before an experience and then compare what they perceive with those expectations. If performance meets expectations, the customer is generally content. If performance exceeds them, the result is positive disconfirmation and higher satisfaction. If performance falls short, the result is negative disconfirmation and dissatisfaction.

Marketing texts, including those by Philip Kotler, commonly describe satisfaction in this way: a comparison between perceived performance and expectations.

In research, this model suggests a practical design. Measure expectations and perceived performance, either separately or as a gap. Measure expectations before the experience where you can, because asking about expectations afterward can be shaped by what the customer now thinks happened.

A 2017 study of bank customers in Ghana used this framework. It found that expectations exceeded perceptions for the sample of 150 customers at three branches of one bank in a single township. The authors note that the results could not be generalized beyond that setting, which is a limit to keep in mind when reading any single study.

SERVQUAL and service quality

SERVQUAL is a widely cited framework for service quality. It measures five dimensions:

  • Tangibles. Physical facilities, equipment, and the appearance of staff and materials.
  • Reliability. The ability to perform the promised service dependably and accurately.
  • Responsiveness. The willingness to help customers and provide prompt service.
  • Assurance. The knowledge and courtesy of staff, and their ability to inspire trust.
  • Empathy. Individual attention given to customers.

The original approach asks customers to rate their expectations and then their perceptions on statements for each dimension. The gap between the two is the quality score. Some researchers use SERVPERF, which measures perceptions alone and is simpler to administer. The gap approach has been debated, so state which version you use and why.

The ACSI-style structural model

The American Customer Satisfaction Index (ACSI) uses a structural model in which drivers such as customer expectations, perceived quality, and perceived value influence customer satisfaction. Satisfaction, in turn, is linked to outcomes such as customer complaints and customer loyalty.

Researchers who use this kind of model typically survey several items for each construct and then test the relationships with structural equation modeling. You do not need to run that analysis to benefit from the idea. A simpler version is to ask customers about the drivers, satisfaction, and loyalty in the same survey, and then compare how the drivers relate to each outcome.

The Kano model

The Kano model sorts product or service attributes by how their presence or absence affects satisfaction. It commonly uses five categories rather than five requirements:

  • Must-be. Customers expect these. Their absence causes dissatisfaction, but their presence adds little satisfaction.
  • One-dimensional (performance). Satisfaction rises as the attribute improves and falls as it gets worse.
  • Attractive (excitement). Customers do not expect these. Their presence can delight, though their absence usually does not cause dissatisfaction.
  • Indifferent. Customers do not care either way.
  • Reverse. For some customers, the presence of the attribute causes dissatisfaction.

Kano categories are usually identified with paired questions: one asks how the customer would feel if the feature were present, and the other asks how they would feel if it were absent. This approach helps prioritize features, though it needs a carefully designed survey and a sample large enough to show the pattern.

Choosing a model for your research

Model Use it when Typical method
Expectation-disconfirmation You want to know whether performance meets expectations Ask about expectations and perceived performance
SERVQUAL or SERVPERF You want to measure service quality across several dimensions Multi-item rating scales
ACSI-style structural model You want to test how drivers lead to satisfaction and loyalty Multi-item survey with structural equation modeling
Kano model You want to prioritize features by their effect on satisfaction Paired functional and dysfunctional questions

If your goal is a simple satisfaction measure to track over time, you may not need a formal model at all. A model becomes more useful when you need to explain why satisfaction changes.

Using models with caution

  • Models simplify. They may leave out local factors that matter to your customers.
  • Results rarely generalize. A study of one branch, one region, or one product line describes that setting. Check the sample before applying the findings elsewhere.
  • Measurement drives quality. A model is only as good as its questions. Use clear items, pretest them, and check that they measure what you intend.
  • Keep wording stable. If you track a model over time, use the same items and scales each time, as with any tracking study.

Next steps

For the planning steps that come before choosing a model, see planning customer satisfaction research. For the basics of survey design, see customer satisfaction surveys. For a single, widely used satisfaction metric, see what CSAT and KPI mean. For loyalty outcomes, see customer loyalty surveys.

The complete guide to customer satisfaction

Customer Satisfaction Surveys: Purpose, Measurement, Pros and Cons
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →